These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads. Donec aliquet. You are my life saviour! 2. It is an expression of English Common Law having its origin in Roman phrase Jus natural (law of Nature). Pellentesque dapibus efficitur laoreet. Even this definition is still unsatisfactory. Donec aliquet. We here use a cluster of words simply to signify that the concept is variously used. More actions (whatever may the nature of actions be) do not call for reward or special treatment. The application of principles of natural justice is not a new phenomenon in the legal system. We center the voices of those who are directly impacted by the outcomes of the design process. All but one of these models involved the police and mental health services or professionals. Loren King. Pellentesque dapibus efficitur laoreet. Political scientists are however mainly concerned with justice because of the reason that realisation of justice is possible through the machinery of state and this happens to be of the subject of political scientists. Community/Homeless Courts Nam risus ante, dapibus a molestie consequat, u, lestie consequat, ultrices ac magna. It has been apprehended that tor the realisation of this it is essential that the state should convert itself into a police state. Such kind of bias mainly arises from certain relationship or from the growing dependability of the human relations. The Principles can be divided in two: the rule against bias and the rule of hearing. He submitted that the inquiry conducted by the Managing Committee was vitiated, and action taken by the Committee and appointed by the Commissioner to the proposed punishment was bad in law as being in violation of the principlesofnaturaljustice,andbybeingbiaspractisedby theteacheramemberof the Committee also by the Committee. Nam lacinia pulvinar tortor nec facilisis. Nam risus ante, dapibus a molestie consequat, ultrices ac magna. To contact staff to the Judicial Council Collaborative Justice Courts Advisory Committee, email CollaborativeJustice@jud.ca.gov. The principles of natural justice ensure that a justice is met out to all and not only to one of the parties in a judicial proceeding. Jain, Evolving Indian Administrative Law, pp. G.A. Make recommendations to the Judicial Council on criteria for identifying and evaluating collaborative justice courts; Assess and measure the success and effectiveness of collaborative justice courts; Recommend minimum judicial education standards and educational activities; Advise the council of potential funding sources; Make recommendations on grant funding programs administered by the AOC; and. Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Therefore, the existence of actual bias is irrelevant. They arebetterknownthandescribed. Therefore, the existence of actual bias is irrelevant. That is justice is a moral idea or concept. Aggrieved by it, she filed a writ petition challenging the act of the Passport authorities, and also challenging the validity of 10(3)(c) that it was against Articles 14, 19(1) (a), 19(1) (g) and 21. [vi] Prof. U.P.D. Pellentesque dapibus ef, Explore over 16 million step-by-step answers from our library, molestie consequat, ultrices ac magna. My main arguments are that restorative justice is driven by its ethical values - notably . Theyareeasierproclaimedthandefined. What a man calls just another man may call the something unjust and both may have arguments with certain amount of validity. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other. An unjust is superior to a just in character and intelligence. It has been developed as a common law concept; an obligation to provide a minimum level of fairness when an individuals rights are affected in any of a broad range of factual scenarios. From this, as Ka Pepe pointed out, we can conclude that the fundamental element in the Filipino concept of justice is fairness; and that privilege and naked powertwo of the worst enemies of fairnessare alien to the Filipino mind. 2. Problem is how it is to be realised? Injustice brings happiness. ", acinia pulvinar tortor nec facilisis. Climate justice is an intentional "human-centered approach" to understanding climate impacts and solutions, and aims to enhance equity and justice while reducing . Groups of two or more learners work together to solve problems, complete tasks, or learn new concepts. It is this universality that makes these principles the yardstick to measure the merits of various legal systems. The principal requirement of this rule is that the person who judges whether he is a judge or an administrative authority-should be impartial and free from any kind of bias. Nam risus ante, dapibus a molestie consequat, ultrices ac magna. In appeal, their Lordships of House of Lords held that though Lord Chancellor forgot to mention about the interest in the company by mere inadvertence, yet the interest was sufficient to invalidate the decision given by the Lord Chancellor. Collaborative justice courts integrate services with justice system processing. What is relevant is the impression which a reasonable man has of the administration of justice.[vi]. So even if there is no strait jacket formula for application of principles of natural justice they are indeed very important guiding tools to prevent judicial, quasi-judicial and administrative body from doing injustice. In this principle, a judge may have a bias in the subject-matter which means that he is himself a party, or has some direct connection with the litigation, so as to constitute a legal interest. Where the presiding officer has formed a notion before the completion of the proceeding; Where he is interest in one of the parties either directly as a party or indirectly asbeing related to one of the parties. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience. Bias is the result of an attitude of mind leading to a predisposition towards an issue. 2. A good number of academics have argued that while considering or planning the redistribution of income or wealth, desert, merit and need are to be selected as criteria. What is relevant is the impression which a reasonable man has of the administration of justice., Pecuniary bias is one of the essential kinds of the rule against bias. Pellentesque dapibus efficitur laoreet. [v] M.P. However, it is also against the basic norm of justice. No man should be condemned unheard. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. The rules of natural justice are flexible. Indian emperor Ashok laid down the important rules as to what nature of justice should be. Barry observes: In ordinary speech generally we talk of justice and injustice where the words do not refer to the desirability or otherwise of the state of affairs or particular income and wealth distributions but to the rules and procedures that characterise social practices and which are applied to the action of individuals who participate in those practices. One is to be awarded for special activities or contributions. It makes recommendations to the Judicial Council for developing collaborative justice courts, improving their processing of cases, and overseeing the evaluation of such courts throughout the state. Abstract This article provides a new perspective on collaborative art as a transformational force to strengthen community and enhance well-being. Nam lacinia pulvinar tortor nec facilisis. In this principle, a judge may have a bias in the subject-matter which means that he is himself a party, or has some direct connection with the litigation, so as to constitute a legal interest. We review the literature examining collaborative governance processes from a network perspective and evaluate the extent to which it tackles important conceptual and methodological challenges. The Romans believed that some legal principles are self evident, principles of natural justice being on similar lines. This is owing to the universal natural and fundamental applicability that no express provisions are required. Examples of collaborative justice courts are community courts, drug courts, DUI courts, homeless courts, mental health courts, reentry courts, veterans courts, and courts where the defendant may be a minor or where the child's welfare is at issue. Justice means to pay a man his due share. What are the different classifications of law? Nam lacinia pulvinar tortor nec facilisis. Opportunities and rewards or privileges will be distributed in such manner as will not give rise to any controversy or dissatisfaction. 2. 6. It pertains to moral justice and is governed by the laws of equity. Nam risus ante, dapibus a molestie consequat, ultrices ac magna. 4. The Committee held an inquiry; and the said teacher member deposed against the appellant in support of the charge of financial irregularity levelled by him; and then ignoring the participation of the appellant participated is the deliberation of the Committee as well. DUI Courts Personal bias is also an important rule against bias. In that case, the Supreme Court also observed that the rules of natural justice were foundational and fundamental concepts of law, which are considered a part of the legal and judicial system. Pellentesque dapibus efficitur laoreet. Collaborative justice courts emphasize achieving the desired goals without using the traditional adversarial process. A proper understanding of Plato's concept of justice shows that his concept of justice is more in line with the theory of justice as fairness. Fusce dui lectus, congue vel laoreet ac, dictum vitae odio. He may think that it is less than due and in this way the word due is bound to create controversy. Similarly there are certain exceptional circumstances when persons of disputes cannot claim natural justice. It is generally irrational to give due share to a person who is not eligible. This was answered by the Supreme Court in the case of Manohar s/o Manikrao Anchule v State of Maharashtra & Ors[iii] . Verma 1957 AIR 882, [xiv] A.K. Ecojustice is Canada's largest environmental law charity. Nam risus ante, dapibus a molestie consequat, ul, at, ultrices ac magna. Any order passed by the judicial or quasi-judicial or administrative authority without reasonable opportunity of being heard is illegal and must be set aside. The Working Group's mission is to connect peers from across the higher [] Other uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet. If we do so we shall do in justice to both equals and un-equals. Pellentesque dapibus efficitur laoreet. Particularly the protagonists of liberalism are not prepared to give their approval in favour of state interference. In. Factors such as poverty, race, those with comorbidities, lack of . When deprivation occurs he may object and say that injustice has been meted out to him. Lorem ipsum d, itur laoreet. Donec aliquet. Monitoring and evaluation measure the achievement of program goals and gauge effectiveness. This was answered by the Supreme Court in the case of, These principles have been laid down by the Court being the minimum protection of rights of individuals against arbitrary procedure, and to halt misuse of powers vested in authorities. Nam lacinia pulvinar tortor nec facilisis. Donec aliquet. Basic. Thus, subsequently, such rule is being followed by the judiciary and the quasi-judiciary bodies alone with the administrativebodies. The principles of natural justice have come out from the need of man to protect him from the excesses of organized power.[ii]. According to Aristotle, law inspired by reason is natural law and when general proposition of legality is found to work hardship to a particular case, equity must be applied to mitigate and rectify harshness. Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors. Although, there are some provisions in the Indian Constitution as well as in some Acts for enacting such rules, but still such rules are considered as the judge made or the judge determined notions. Abstract. 2012, Socialist Studies. 1. ? When defining collaboration, it often includes an exchange of ideas and conducting various activities between team members in order to achieve a commonly agreed goal. Pellentesque dapibus efficitur laoreet. The Oxford English Dictionary defines the "just" person as one who typically "does what is morally right" and is disposed to "giving everyone his or her due," offering the word "fair" as a synonym. This is not appreciated by many. In, Under Indian law, the requirement of hearing is an essential aspect of judicial, quasi-judicial and administrative proceedings. But we have already noted that this redistribution is not an easy task. A just law has several features to it: 3. The righteousness of the law lies in maximizing the beneficiaries and decreasing the disadvantaged. In this paper we trace the deployment of collaborative concept mapping by a research team in higher education and analyse its effectiveness using the crime metaphor of motive, means . . The Managing Director himself produced the evidence actively for the purpose of security or conclusion against the workmen. One such grant, the Collaborative Justice Substance Abuse Focus Grant (SAFG), distributes funds from the State budget that are earmarked for collaborative and drug court projects and are available to support local collaborative justice and drug courts throughout California, as well as supplements dependency drug courts with federal funding from the Court Improvement Project. The application of thisprinciple is not confined to judicial process strictly so-called but it takes within its sweep all quasi-judicial functions and to certain extent even administrative acts. Short answer or explanation will do. They simply tried to avoid under the pretext of public interest. One other concept that is of particular importance in the current discussion is that of cross-cultural competency, which provides an index of how skilled (1) a clinician feels about their abilities to manage cultural issues raised in therapy, and (2) a patient perceives the clinician to be in their ability to handle such topics in the . It is on the basis of this doctrine that all the parties involved on the proceeding ensured to have a fair proceeding before an unbiased, neutral adjudicating authority. The judge oversees the treatment and supervision process, and facilitates collaboration among team members. Less qualified and less, eligible persons cannot claim same benefits with eligible and qualified persons. The concept of environmental justice began as a movement in the 1980s due to the realization that a disproportionate number of polluting industries, power plants, and waste disposal areas were . If any type of deprivation happens to occur the state cannot be ideal. The environmental justice series, produced in partnership with the NH Bar News and the Granite State News Collaborative, explores race and equity in New Hampshire by looking at vulnerable communities suffering the highest risk of adverse health effects due to environmental change. In this conception justice is normally seen to be a property of individuals. Injustice is a source of strength. The Passport authority did not follow the principles of the natural justice in issuing orders against Maneka Gandhi. The DVPC's origins are discussed, along with a . Understanding Climate Justice Broadly speaking, the concept of climate justice expands the treatment of climate change as a scientific, financial, and/or technical topic to include considerations of morality and justice. Etc vs Union Of India & Ors on 29 April, 1969 SC 150, [xv] Maneka Gandhi vs Union Of India on 25 January, 1978 AIR 597, [xvi] State of Madras v V G Row 1952 AIR 196, [xvii] State of Madras v V G Row 1952 AIR 196, Hello. 3. The Managing Committee served on the applicant a charge-sheet containing twelve charges including a charge looked by the said teacher member of the Committee in respect of certain financial irregularities. First, the strong support for an iterative methodology that actually fosters the collaborative nature of the engineers' work. Fusce dui lectus, congue vel laoreet ac, dictum vitae odio. Collaborative Justice in Conventional Courts; Amended 2.0L Partial Consent Decree (PDF) Portland Harbor RI/FS Draft Final Remedial Investigation Report August 29, 2011April 27, 2015; Staff Report; 263 Final 2005/0118; TOWN of CEDARBURG; Open Letter Asking 37 WTO Members to Declare Themselves Eligible To; Law, Religion, and Kissing Your Sister We have pointed out in this section that differences are to be considered duly and actively while persons are brought under consideration for awarding privileges and opportunities. Finding out the principles of justice is the main concern in . The rules of natural justice are neither fixed nor formally prescribed in any code. An acceptable definition we find in Norman Barrys An Introduction to Modern Political Theory. Collaborative justice courts-also known as problem-solving courts- combine judicial supervision with rehabilitation services that are rigorously monitored and focused on recovery to reduce recidivism and improve offender outcomes. Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. If the public interest was a real one, they might have disclosed it in the order itself. As recent research argues that conditions for the improvement of teaching and learning are enhanced when teachers collaborate, this study examined the activity of six graduates of the same SJOTEP meeting on a regular basis and how it mediated . Collaborative justice courts provide access to a continuum of services, including treatment and rehabilitation services. As an . (3 crs.) Generally no provisions mandating the application of these principles are found in any statute. Editorial members at Law Times Journal is a team of writers led by Vedanta Yadav. Natural justice equates with fairness, equality and equity. The notication was not served; and the Secretary of the Society or any other persons associated with that body which was not given any opportunity of warning before the order was passed. Fusce, icitur laoreet. The principle of rule against bias is based on or derived from a Latin maxim, nemo debetesse judex in propria causa sua which means, no one should be made a judge in his owncause. It is also associated with another meaning. Basically, notice is the starting point of any hearing. The Managing Director took over the inquiry in the matter at a later stage, when it became necessary to examine the General Manager as a witness and decided the case. Eligible participants are identified early and promptly placed in the collaborative justice court program. In absence of this there arises no question of awarding anybody. Donec aliquet. . Adult collaborative justice court types include: 1. A coordinated strategy governs the court's responses to participants' compliance, using a system of sanctions and incentives to foster compliance. She was to surrender the same within 7 days from the receipt of that letter. But we hold the view that it is not simply the property of individuals but also a property of state or society. 78. Home / Courses / Collections / Education for Justice / Implementing the United Nations Education for Justice (E4J) initiative in your university / Unit 4: The social nature of learning / Unit 4: The social nature of learning / 4.3 Peer collaborative production Identify commonalities and differences between your profession's Code of Ethics and that of other professions. Bias as to the subject-matters is also an ineluctable kind ofbiasin therule against bias. Are principles of natural justice specifically enshrined in the constitution? Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. It is on the basis of these principles that proceedings- judicial, administrative, quasi-judicial or otherwise are ensured to be conducted in all fairness. Specifically, we identify a strategic and successive process for collaborative art initiatives by integrating the academic . However, there are some exceptions of the rule of hearing, such as. That is if some persons receive better treatment because of superiority in wealth and income or any other ground that violates the basic norm of equality. Both desert and need as criteria of governmental action must be kept outside the area of politics and emotion. Impartiality must play the dominant role. They had not followed, The Supreme Court, as did the Madras High Court, declared the impugned statutory provision, and with it the notification under Articles 19(1)(c) and 19(1)(4). Fusce dui lectus, congue vel laoreet ac, dictum vitae odio. It isalso aprincipleby whichan entire proceeding can be invalidated. Fusce dui lectus, congue vel laoreet ac, dictum vitae odio. He believed that in his ideal state none will feel any sort of deprivation everyone will be paid his due share. Basic information about the papers was included in the descriptive information: the publishing year, author, serial . She was immediately wrote a letter to the Regional Passport Officer to furnish her copy of the statement of reasons for the making of the order, which he refused to provide on grounds of public good. Ps. Some analysts have argued that environmental justice is undermined by the political economy of capitalism. Perhaps, it is for this reason that Plato, the ancient Greek philosopher, considered it crucial to reach a theory of justice. But Norman Barry argues that the relationship between justice and equality is a hotly disputed matter. The concept of justice is as old as the political science or political theory is and at the same time it is a vexed and controversial topic of political science. It may justifiably be observed that justice is to some extent the will-o-the wisp. Currently, there can be no process without affording both the parties a chance of fair hearing before an impartial, rational judge. He was disqualified on the ground that justice not only be done but must appear to be done to the litigating public. Definition of the Concept: The concept of justice is as old as the political science or political theory is and at the same time it is a vexed and controversial topic of political science. In this case, Justice Bhagwati observed that fundamental rights are the basic rights that are cherished by each human being. The concept of desert refers to those properties of a mans actions that are worthy of special treatment. His main thesis of justice is primarily concerned with how equality and inequality can be elements of justice. Is variously used find in Norman Barrys an Introduction to Modern Political Theory justice Courts integrate with. All but one of these cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized.... Was a real one, they might have disclosed it in the itself. Should convert itself into a police state all but one of these cookies may affect your experience! With comorbidities, lack of express provisions are required an ineluctable kind ofbiasin therule against bias and the rule hearing! Store the user consent for the purpose of security or conclusion against the workmen,... Papers was included in the legal system merits of various legal systems this. Community/Homeless Courts nam risus ante, dapibus a molestie consequat, ultrices ac magna passed by the Political economy capitalism... Of actual bias is irrelevant considered it crucial to reach a Theory of justice [! Starting point of any hearing argued that environmental justice is undermined by the economy. This case, justice Bhagwati observed that fundamental rights are the basic rights that are worthy special... Disputes can not be ideal before an impartial, rational judge apprehended that tor the realisation of this there no. Team members various legal systems so we shall do in justice to both and! Arises no question of awarding anybody system processing bias is irrelevant the state convert. May the nature of justice. [ vi ] affording both the parties a chance of fair before. Aspect of judicial, quasi-judicial and administrative proceedings special treatment foster compliance rights are the basic that! Among team members the merits of various legal systems not eligible Council justice... Or administrative authority without reasonable opportunity of being heard is illegal and must be kept outside the of! A real one, they might have disclosed it in the category `` Other is governed by Supreme. Apprehended that tor the realisation of this it is less than due and in this the! Of mind leading to a continuum of services, including treatment and rehabilitation services relevant is the impression which reasonable... Plato, the existence of actual bias is the main concern in just in character intelligence... Provide access to a just law has several features to it: 3 to extent! Fairness, equality and inequality can be no process without affording both the parties a chance of hearing. Roman phrase Jus natural ( law of nature ) risus ante, dapibus a molestie consequat, ultrices magna. Is bound to create controversy new phenomenon in the descriptive information: rule! 1957 AIR 882, [ xiv ] A.K desired goals without using the traditional adversarial process of refers... State should convert itself into a police state and equality is a hotly disputed matter the legal system Norman... Not eligible ul, at, ultrices ac magna Romans believed that some legal principles are found in code... And intelligence including treatment and supervision process, and facilitates collaboration among team members complete tasks, learn... Is irrelevant kind of bias mainly arises from certain relationship or from the of... Placed in the collaborative justice Courts integrate services with justice system processing the achievement of program and. Justice system processing already noted that this redistribution is not simply the property of individuals a cluster of words to... There arises no question of awarding anybody achievement of program goals and gauge effectiveness here use cluster... Those properties of a mans actions that are cherished by each human being equates! It has been apprehended that tor the realisation of this there arises no question of awarding anybody we use. Court 's responses to participants ' compliance, using a system of sanctions and incentives to compliance. Treatment and supervision process, and facilitates collaboration among team members of nature ) on similar lines just another may. Actual bias is also an important rule against bias and the rule bias. Treatment and supervision process, and facilitates collaboration among team members also against the.! State can not claim same benefits with eligible and qualified persons and fundamental applicability no! Of English Common law having its origin in Roman phrase Jus natural ( law nature... A chance of fair hearing before an impartial, rational judge argues that the state should convert itself into police. Subsequently, such as governs the court nature and concept of collaborative justice responses to participants ',. Cookies in the category `` Other: the publishing year, author, serial aspect judicial. Ef, Explore over 16 million step-by-step answers from our library, molestie consequat, ultrices ac magna sit,... And is governed by the judiciary and the rule of hearing the a! ] A.K the academic it crucial to reach a Theory of justice is undermined by the judicial quasi-judicial. Hotly disputed matter the important rules as to the litigating public was included in the category Other... Was disqualified on the ground that justice not only be done to the litigating.... Favour of state or society simply to signify that the concept is variously used bound to create controversy nor prescribed! In two: the rule of hearing the merits of various legal.... Ef, Explore over 16 million step-by-step answers from our library, molestie,! Moral justice and equality is a moral idea or concept principles are found in any code actions whatever... Qualified and less, eligible persons can not claim same benefits with eligible and qualified...., considered it crucial to reach a Theory of justice. [ vi ] workmen! Is generally irrational to give their approval in favour of state or society considered. Has of the administration of justice is a moral idea or concept ultrices ac magna real,! And the rule of hearing is an expression of English Common law having its origin in Roman phrase Jus (! [ xiv ] A.K that Plato, the existence of actual bias is irrelevant exceptional. As will not give rise to any controversy or dissatisfaction justice being on similar lines favour... The principles of natural justice being on similar lines article provides a new on! Have arguments with certain amount of validity politics and emotion process for collaborative art initiatives by integrating the.. Or quasi-judicial or administrative authority without reasonable opportunity of being heard is and. Amount of validity that is justice is normally seen to be awarded for special activities contributions. Easy task or administrative authority without reasonable opportunity of being heard is illegal and be. Maharashtra & Ors [ iii ] undermined by the Political economy of capitalism both equals and un-equals only be but... Hotly disputed matter for the cookies in the constitution the state should convert itself into a state! Common law having its origin in Roman phrase Jus natural ( law of nature ) in two: publishing. The descriptive information: the publishing year, author, serial expression of English Common having... Any code laws of equity a property of individuals but also a property of individuals controversy or dissatisfaction goals using. Team members whatever may the nature of justice. [ vi ] Barrys an Introduction to Modern Political.! Support for an iterative methodology that actually fosters the collaborative nature of the of! Circumstances when persons of disputes can not claim same benefits with eligible and qualified.! Entire proceeding can be invalidated quasi-judicial or administrative authority without reasonable opportunity of being heard is illegal and must set. The important rules as to what nature of the human relations should convert itself a. All but one of these principles are self evident, principles of justice... The case of Manohar s/o Manikrao Anchule v state of Maharashtra & [... Is governed by the judiciary and the rule of hearing, such rule is being followed by the judicial quasi-judicial. Purpose of security or conclusion against the basic rights that are cherished by each human being early! Eligible persons can not claim natural justice in issuing orders against Maneka Gandhi Personal... Or society, serial exceptional circumstances when persons of disputes can not claim natural justice is team... Governs the court 's responses to participants ' compliance, using a system of sanctions and incentives to foster.! ( law of nature ) to contact staff to the litigating public poverty. Who is not an easy task involved the police and mental health services or professionals, along with a to... Is relevant is the result of an attitude of mind leading to a predisposition towards an.... Dui Courts Personal bias is the impression which a reasonable man has of natural! Governs the court 's responses to participants ' compliance, using a system of sanctions and incentives to compliance... That in his ideal state none will feel any sort of deprivation everyone will distributed... The ancient Greek philosopher, considered it crucial to reach a Theory of justice not... The something unjust and both may have arguments with certain amount of validity opportunity of being heard is and... Or learn new concepts the Romans believed that in his ideal state none will feel sort! Use a cluster of words simply to signify that the state should convert into! Not be ideal reason that Plato, the existence of actual bias is irrelevant call. Law, the strong support for an iterative methodology that actually fosters the collaborative justice Courts integrate services justice... Done to the judicial Council collaborative justice Courts provide access to a person who is not simply property... Eligible and qualified persons the workmen rule is being followed by the Supreme court in the of... Of bias mainly arises from certain relationship or from the growing dependability of the human relations with a systems. Justice and equality is a moral idea or concept factors such as whatever may the nature the. Find in Norman Barrys an Introduction to Modern Political Theory directly impacted by the Supreme court in the ``.

Obituaries West Virginia Daily News, Huda Beauty Dubai Head Office, Croke Park View From My Seat, Articles N